News

DSET Releases Latest Report, Uncovering Huawei’s Shadow Network and Shenzhen’s Semiconductor Investment Strategy

The Research Institute for Democracy, Society, and Emerging Technology (DSET) has published a policy report titled “Uncovering Huawei’s Shadow Network: The Role of SZMII and Taiwanese Suppliers in China’s Semiconductor Strategy“. The report investigates how Huawei, despite U.S. sanctions, leverages a shadow network to access foreign resources, technologies, and services to expand its semiconductor manufacturing capabilities.

The report was authored by DSET’s Adjunct Analyst Tsai-Yi Wang and Non-resident Fellow Min-Yen Chiang, under the Economic Security Research Program.

On the 2nd of this month, the U.S. government announced new export control measures, adding 140 Chinese entities to its Entity List to curtail China’s capacity to manufacture advanced chips. Companies such as Swaysure, Qingdao SiEn, and Pengxinxu, which collaborate with Huawei in chip production, were among those listed. The report places a spotlight on  Shenzhen Major Industry Investment Group (SZMII), a state-owned investment conglomerate and the controlling entity behind Swaysure and Pengxinxu, both of which were recently sanctioned by the U.S.

Key Findings

SZMII, a state-owned investment conglomerate under the Shenzhen municipal government, controls numerous semiconductor manufacturers. As outlined in Figure 1 of the report, SZMII plays a critical role in allocating resources, establishing semiconductor companies such as Swaysure and Pengxinxu, and maintaining close ties with Huawei through strategic personnel arrangements. The report identifies the following key findings:

  1. To bolster the local semiconductor manufacturing industry, SZMII has forged close ties with Huawei. Within this context, SZMII has adopted three primary investment strategies to build Huawei’s “shadow supply chain”:
    • Encouraging established companies to set up manufacturing facilities in Shenzhen.
    • Integrating private companies into its network through mergers and acquisitions.
    • Founding new entities to directly support Huawei’s supply chain needs.
  2. As detailed in Figure 1, SZMII has established entities such as Swaysure, Pengxinxu, and PXW. These newly created companies, which have minimal publicly available information, serve as intermediaries to engage with Taiwan’s semiconductor supply chain. Through these entities, SZMII has secured technological assistance and expertise.
  3. Compared to prominent Chinese technology giants, these lesser-known startups are better positioned to evade the scrutiny of international governments. Their low profile allows them to acquire technology and services from Taiwanese companies more effectively, ultimately integrating Taiwan’s semiconductor industry expertise into Shenzhen’s—and by extension, China’s—broader national semiconductor strategy.

Dr. Jeremy Chang Chih-Cheng, CEO and Director of the Economic Security Research Program at the DSET, emphasized the global concerns surrounding China’s technological advancements under its authoritarian regime. Dr. Chang highlighted that China’s mastery of advanced semiconductor technology could not only enhance tools used by the regime to oppress human rights but also destabilize geopolitical peace and stability. Tech democracies, including Taiwan, increasingly recognize the necessity of controlling exports of technology and knowledge to China. However, with China’s supply chain operations becoming increasingly opaque, these countries face a significant challenge in investigating supply chain dynamics and implementing export controls or other regulatory measures. Dr. Chang stressed that DSET’s latest policy report aims to enhance international understanding of China’s practices, particularly the commercial pathways through which Chinese firms absorb foreign technology.

DSET Non-resident Fellow Chiang Min-yen pointed to a 2023 Bloomberg report revealing that four Taiwanese companies provided engineering services to PXW and Pengxinxu. This revelation brought Huawei’s shadow network back into public focus. Chiang noted that while media reports play a vital role in fostering public policy discussions related to technology safeguards, further analysis of the underlying business mechanisms and the influence of China’s industrial policies is essential for deepening these conversations. He expressed hope that DSET’s report would enable the international community to grasp the complexities of China’s domestic supply chain dynamics, fostering pragmatic and effective collaborative frameworks among tech democracies.

Tsai-Yi Wang, a DSET adjunct analyst and lead author of the report, explained how China leverages domestic market incentives and local compliance procedures to encourage Taiwanese companies to establish more autonomous subsidiaries within China. This growing autonomy may place these subsidiaries beyond the reach of international regulatory measures. Wang emphasized that this situation serves as a warning for other companies investing in China.

The report examined several cases, including key Chinese semiconductor firms such as Huawei’s shadow network, SMIC, Fujian Jinhua, and ChangXin Memory, which have all received cleanroom engineering services from Taiwanese firms. These commercial ties can be traced back to the early 2000s when Taiwanese wafer manufacturers began investing in China. Despite Taiwan’s government imposing investment review restrictions to safeguard its semiconductor industry’s competitiveness, the complexity of semiconductor production networks has left many suppliers beyond the scope of these reviews.

Wang elaborated that globalization had previously integrated China’s semiconductor industry into global value chains. Under this structure, the successful listing of Taiwanese subsidiaries on Chinese stock markets was once seen as a strategic move to expand global business operations. On one hand, China’s capital markets allowed Taiwanese firms to reduce reliance on funding from their Taiwan-based parent companies, leveraging Chinese capital for local market expansion. On the other hand, the public listing status often enhanced trust with Chinese clients. However, with the current U.S.-China technology rivalry, this structure has been upended. What was once an advantage now exposes Taiwanese firms to greater constraints, undermining Taiwan’s economic security policies. The DSET report provides a comprehensive analysis of this historical development.

Wang emphasized that the supply chain research report should be seen as a step toward strengthening Taiwan’s economic security framework. For businesses, understanding the political implications of specific commercial mechanisms can help mitigate future geopolitical risks. For Taiwanese society, addressing contemporary issues rooted in past industrial developments can steer public discussions toward critical policy priorities. For the international community, the report offers a reliable foundation for devising policies that prevent corporations from being absorbed into China’s state-driven semiconductor strategy.

Share This News

Related News

Event News

European Delegation Visits DSET for Discussions on Economic Security

2024 / 12 / 3

Event News

German Environmental Law Scholar Thomas Schomerus Visits DSET to Discuss Semiconductor Industry Resource Challenges

2024 / 11 / 29

Announcement

Cybersecurity Risk Advisory

2024 / 11 / 15